The real estate market has undergone significant shifts over the past few years, particularly in how interest rates have affected homeowners’ decisions. Many homeowners who purchased during the pandemic secured record-low interest rates, sometimes as low as 2.5%. Now, with rates hovering around 7%, these homeowners face a dilemma: should they sell and upsize, or rent out their current home and explore alternative financial strategies?
In this article, we’ll break down the financials of renting versus selling for different types of homeowners and help you determine the best path forward based on your unique situation.
Homeowners Who Bought During the Pandemic and Need More Space
The Challenge: Many families who purchased a starter home between 2020-2022 are now outgrowing their space. However, with their current mortgage locked in at historically low rates, moving up to a larger home at today’s higher rates can feel financially overwhelming.
Renting vs. Selling Considerations:
- Renting: Keeping the home as a rental could be a strategic move, especially if the mortgage payment is significantly lower than potential rental income. This can generate cash flow while allowing homeowners to wait for a better rate environment before purchasing their next home.
- Selling: While selling allows access to equity for a down payment on a larger home, it also means giving up the low-rate mortgage. The key financial consideration is whether the increased monthly payment on a new mortgage at current rates is sustainable.
Key Question: Does your current home make sense as a rental property, or is the need for equity to upsize more pressing?
Homeowners Considering Becoming Accidental Landlords
The Challenge: Some homeowners are considering renting their homes to avoid selling in a market with limited inventory. While interest rates have impacted affordability for some buyers, demand remains strong, and buyers continue to compete for well-priced homes.
Renting vs. Selling Considerations:
- Renting: If rental rates in the area exceed the mortgage payment and cover maintenance, this could be a viable wealth-building strategy. However, being a landlord means dealing with tenant management, property maintenance, and potential vacancies.
- Selling: If the equity in the home is substantial, selling could free up capital for a new home purchase or alternative investments. However, inventory constraints mean that finding the next home can be a challenge.
Key Question: Are you financially and mentally prepared to manage a rental property, or is selling the better long-term move?
Homeowners Looking to Relocate for Work or Lifestyle Reasons
The Challenge: Whether moving for a job opportunity, better schools, or lifestyle changes, homeowners facing relocation must decide whether to keep their current home as an investment property or sell and start fresh elsewhere.
Renting vs. Selling Considerations:
- Renting: If the local rental market is strong, keeping the home as an income-generating asset while moving could be a smart play.
- Selling: Selling allows for a clean break and simplifies finances, eliminating the need for remote property management.
Key Question: Does maintaining a rental property from a distance align with your financial and personal goals?
Additional Factors to Consider When Deciding
- Equity Position: If you have built substantial equity, selling could provide the capital needed for your next move. If equity is limited, renting may allow for future appreciation.
- Market Conditions: While demand remains strong, low inventory is a major factor affecting both buyers and sellers. Selling in a low-inventory market could mean favorable conditions for sellers, while renting allows for appreciation over time.
- Cash Flow Analysis: If renting, does the potential rental income exceed your mortgage and maintenance costs? A negative cash flow scenario could make selling the better option.
- Long-Term Investment Strategy: Do you want to build wealth through real estate, or do you prefer liquidity for other investments?
- Tax Implications: Selling may result in capital gains taxes, while rental properties offer deductions but require tax planning.
Conclusion: What’s the Right Move for You?
Deciding between renting and selling requires a thorough understanding of both personal financial goals and current market conditions. For homeowners with pandemic-era mortgage rates, the “golden handcuffs” make moving up more complicated, but strategic rental investments could be a worthwhile alternative.
Every situation is unique, and working with a knowledgeable real estate professional can help you weigh your options effectively. Whether you choose to rent or sell, the key is making an informed decision that aligns with both your financial and lifestyle goals.
matthewpasciuta.com 
Leave a comment